Tucked In Vs Untucked Shirts

Written by Dan | 25/07/2023


Get The Look

Welcome to the world of shirts where one simple decision – to tuck or not to tuck – can change your entire look! Our all-in-one guide, “Tucked vs Untucked Shirts” is here to take you through the ins and outs of these two styles.

Whether you’re heading to a job interview or catching up with friends at the pub, knowing how and when to rock each style can make all the difference. At Mainline Menswear, we’ve got a wide range of modern and traditional shirts that can help you effortlessly nail both looks.

And guess what? We’ll also let you in on some common style blunders guys often make while trying out these styles, and how you can avoid them. So, if you’re ready to up your shirt game and make a solid impression wherever you go, keep reading!


A man in an untucked shirt by the seaside

Tucked Shirts: The Basics

A tucked-in shirt is often associated with a more formal, polished look. It’s the go-to style for business meetings, formal events, or any occasion where you want to appear professional and put-together.

At Mainline Menswear, we offer a variety of options from crisp white dress shirts perfect for that big presentation to patterned designs that add a touch of personality to your formal attire.

However, tucking in your shirt isn’t as simple as it seems. One common mistake is not ensuring the shirt fits well – shirts that are too large can bunch excess fabric up around the waist, creating an unflattering ‘muffin-top’ effect. Always opt for a shirt that fits comfortably around your body when tucked in.

How To Tuck in a Shirt

Tucking in a shirt might seem like a no-brainer but doing it correctly can elevate your style and give you a more polished look. Start by buttoning up your shirt and leaving your pants unfastened. Carefully tuck your shirt into your pants, ensuring it’s smooth and flat against your body.

Next, fasten your pants and do a quick ‘shirt puff’ – gently pull up your shirt to create just enough slack for movement. This step helps prevent your shirt from pulling out when you sit or move.

A common mistake is skipping the belt, but it’s a crucial accessory that holds your shirt in place and adds a finished look to your outfit. Remember, the goal is a clean, streamlined appearance, so take a moment to check yourself in the mirror and smooth out any wrinkles or bunching. With practice, you’ll be able to nail the perfect shirt tuck every time!

For occasions that demand a smart tucked-in look, we recommend a classic Oxford dress shirt like this one from Ralph Lauren:

Ralph Lauren Slim Fit Oxford Shirt

Ralph Lauren Slim Fit Oxford Shirt


Untucked Shirts: When Casual Meets Cool

Untucked shirts offer a relaxed, easy-going vibe. Ideal for casual outings, weekend brunches, or even a laid-back office environment, they embody effortless cool. Mainline Menswear’s selection ranges from trendy checked casual shirts to timeless solid colours, perfect for nailing that untucked look.

But there’s a catch – the length matters! A common error is a shirt that’s too long or too short when worn untucked. The ideal untucked shirt should hit around the middle of your zip or back pockets. Anything longer could look more like a dress than a stylish custom shirt!

Our pick for that laidback look:

Tommy Hilfiger Long Sleeve Check Shirt

Tommy Hilfiger Long Sleeve Check Shirt


Unbuttoned Shirts Over a Tee: The Layered Look

Another popular style to consider is the unbuttoned shirt worn over a classic cotton tee. This laid-back look screams casual cool and is perfect for those relaxed weekend getaways, outdoor concerts, or casual hangouts with friends. The best part is that many choices on offer are wrinkle-free styles that skilfully resist pesky creases.

Layering a short-sleeve shirt over a T-shirt is a classic style that offers endless possibilities for mixing and matching colours and patterns. This casual look allows you to express your personal style while adding an extra dimension to your outfit. We love this striking short-sleeve piece from Ted Baker:

Ted Baker Sallins Floral Print Shirt

Ted Baker Sallins Floral Print Shirt


When it comes to choosing colours, consider the colour wheel. Complementary colours (those opposite each other on the colour wheel) create a vibrant look, while analogous colours (those next to each other) offer a more put-together feel. For instance, a blue tee paired with an orange checked short-sleeve shirt can make a bold statement.

If bold patterns are your thing, remember the rule of thumb – pair a patterned piece with a solid one to balance the look. So, if you’re wearing a striped or floral untucked shirt, pair it with a solid-colour tee.

The key is to have fun with your choices and let your personality shine through your outfit. With the diverse range of wrinkle free shirts at Mainline Menswear, you’re sure to find the perfect styles that will turn heads wherever you go!

Vivienne Westwood Short Sleeved Shirt

Vivienne Westwood Short Sleeved Shirt


Remember, this style works best when the untucked shirt and tee are not too baggy or too tight – you’re aiming for a comfortable, easy fit. It’s a common mistake to overlook the fit, but getting it right can take your layered look from sloppy to sleek in no time!


The Polo Shirt Dilemma

When it comes to polo shirts, the tuck-in debate is a tricky one. Traditionally, polo shirts were designed to be worn untucked, offering a sporty, relaxed look that’s perfect for casual outings or a round of golf in warm weather. However, modern fashion rules have become more flexible, and there are times when a tucked-in polo can work well.

If you’re attending a semi-formal event or a smart-casual work environment, tucking in your polo can add a touch of sophistication. The key here is to ensure the polo isn’t too long – it should hit around the mid-hip area, and it should fit well, not too tight, or too loose.

A common mistake is to leave the shirt untucked when it’s clearly too long, resulting in a sloppy look. So, whether you choose to tuck or untuck your polo, make sure it’s appropriate for the occasion and fits well for a sharp, stylish appearance.

Fred Perry Twin Tipped Polo

Fred Perry Twin Tipped Polo


Final Thoughts

Whether you prefer the neatness of a tucked look or the breezy style of an untucked shirt, the key is to understand when each style works best. Remember, fashion rules are not set in stone. Feel free to experiment with your personal preference and find what feels most comfortable for you. After all, confidence is the ultimate style statement!

Stay ahead of the fashion curve and get your shirting fix at Mainline Menswear. We’ve got you covered! So, what are you waiting for? Check out our selection today and find your ideal shirt.



Find your perfect shirt with Mainline Menswear



What did you think of this post?


Thumbs up review image


Average review image

Not for me!

Thumbs down review image